Season 5 episode discussion (Stream & episode links in first post)

Do you think the egg could hatch?

@Background Pony #2415  
Probably far too old.
 
Unless all it needs is magical heat.

@MrXemnas1992
 
I sort of remember. of course, i wasn’t around back then, so i remember it only from the things i read when i was still sort of interested in the show, but still reading only the fanfics and the TvTropes pages.

@MrXemnas1992  
I remember that. Thought it was stupid back then, and now it’s debunked.

@SeraphimDawn  
It’s been debunked for quite awhile.

I loved the way as the Pie rock farm turned out being an amazing place, full of glowing crystals all over the place.  
Amish Pies were also fun to see.

Was cool to finally see Blinkie/Limestone and Inkie/Marble as grown mares for the first time. The way that they celebrated Hearth’s Warming was expected for the Pies. Interesting interaction with the Apples and Pies in the episode. Ending was cute and a tearjerker for me during that scene with AJ and Pinkie in the crystal cave. Like the fact that they brought up the idea of the Pies and Apples sharing a uneven connection to an extent and possibly being related.
 
Overall, I give it 9/10.

Limestone key Pie is my favorite pie.  
Parents were cool too.

 
Tom’s grandfather

@Anonycat  
The crystals everywhere were a nice touch. Had a hunch rock farm could translate into mine.

>screencaps: Pie family is canon  
I love you, season 5. You touch me in all the right places.

Also funny thing, Pinkie and her sisters represent the four humors

I forget. Did they say whether Limestone is older or younger than Pinkie?

@Dustcan  

 
Pinkie by a few minutes.

@schpeelah  
I thought that was Marble.

@schpeelah
 
No, that was Marble.

@soundtea  
interesting

@Jarkes  

 
Ah right. Mixed it up because there should be no confusion with the other one, since there should be no ambiguity with the other one: since Marble is the youngest, and Pinkie is her twin, Limestone must be older.
 
The only question is whether she’s older then Maud. I think she’s younger, and is so insistent on being the boss because she wouldn’t be if Maud didn’t move out to make a degree, making her insecure and feeling threatened.

@schpeelah  
yeah that sounds right to me

@soundtea  
Let me get this straight; Pinkie Pie is “Blood”, Limestone is “Yellow Bile”, Marble is “Black Bile”, and Maud Pie is “Phlegm”. Am I right?

@Joshua  
Yes. Sanguine, choleric, melancholy, and phlegmatic.

@Joshua  

 
Pinkie  
Temperament: Saunguine (courageous, hopeful, playful, carefree),  
Element: Air (balloons, the PinkieCopter, the bouncing),  
Season: Spring,  
Organ: Heart (of course),  
Humor: Blood (hence pink)
 
Maud  
Temperament: Phlegmatic (calm, thoughtful, patient, peaceful),  
Element: Water (Maud smashes rock as if flowing through it, her thrown rocks cause tsunami even in lakes),  
Season: Winter,  
Organ: brain (the doctorate!),  
Humor: Phlegm
 
Limestone  
Temperament: Choleric (ambitious, leader-like, restless, easily angered),  
Element: Fire,  
Season: Summer,  
Organ: Liver,  
Humor: Yellow bile
 
Marble  
Temperament: Melancholic (despondent, quiet, analytical, serious),  
Element: Earth,  
Season: Autumn,  
Organ: Spleen,  
Humor: Black bile

@schpeelah  
Limestone is the liver?
 
My margarita/bartender headcanon suddenly makes more sense than I meant it to.

@PonyPon  

 
I suppose the Lime&Stone cutie mark might be tangentially related as well?

@schpeelah  
Yeah, because that stone looks much like salt.
 
Come to think of it, a rare fanon was that salt was what ponies had in lieu of alcohol….