@Skystrike92  
Truthfully, Fo:E cannot exist without FiM, and they exist in different niches. So it’s better to say that as an adult fan fiction about friendship, Fo:E is superior, but as a family friendly story about friendship, FiM is superior.

I love fallout equestria. But even it is not as good as original mlp.

@Background Pony #99E5
 
50 years dungeon it is.

Original MLP > Fallout Equestria > Fall of Equestria
 
Sue me. <3

that’s true tho.

@Lord Mega  
No, the inventor of dark and edgy was Warhammer 40k. “In the GRIM DARKness of the year 40,000…”  
That’s where that word, grimdark, comes from. Can’t get much darker and edgier than that, really.

@Ravemastaj  
PH has a lot of songs. “At the End of the Trail” might not count, but is amazing; “Shoulda Just Sent the Whisky” probably does; the song from that one version of “Jack and the Beanstalk” would. And there are others. If you’re familiar with horizon’s (the author) Versebreaker setting, I’ve said before that I think of PH as almost being one, since the same thing kind of comes up.
 
 
@infinita est lux Solis  
I give it to PH on both, but if I’m choosing one it’s definitely the characters.

@Ihhh  
basically the inventor of the concept dark and edgy, and it’s the reason everyone who has played a sonic the hedgehog game knows about him.

@Lord Mega  
Who?

@Ihhh  
why do you think so many people like shadow the hedgehog?

@Ihhh  
Sometimes darker does equal better

Darker ≠ better. Dark ≯ lighthearted.

finally, someone who knows whats up.

It would’ve been better if it had been called “My LittlePip: Fallout induces Mutations.” Wasted opportunity. But overall it had a good story and great characters.

@Ravemastaj  
I preferred the original’s story, but PH’s characters were better.

@QueenChrysalisIsBestVillain  
No songs? What about the Giggle at the Ghosty spoof that Blackjack did? And the “May the best pet win” spoof that Murky Number 7 did? I’m sure there were a couple others as well.

WHO DOWNVOTED THIS?!?
 
Project Horizons was great. Murky Number 7 was also good. The original was meh.

If you prefer it, then that’s your preference. I can’t argue with that ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

I started reading the original piece but I end up not going further with it… personally I don’t like the actual Fallout games but the fiction is quite decent and has its merits.
 
Even if I never end up too hook up to it I do like mentioning that specially from Russian artists there’s a lot of great fan-art of it.

Fallout Equestria is good, but it’s not the masterpiece the fandom keeps saying.

@justanotherponi  
No…

@mjangelvortex  

 
I speak fluent Duck.
 
He’s telling us all to go F*ck ourselves.

I like Fallout Equestria too, but it is not better than the show. For one thing, there are no songs (Velvet Remedey singing doesn’t count because she just sings normally on stage, not impromptu musical numbers).

@Driver Nephi  
Not too surprised to hear that. Quite a bit of crossovers are like that.

No. Sit down Op