I liked the intricacy a lot. My only issue is how arbitrary the good ending/bad ending section is.

I’m making out with Queen Chrysalis in Celestia’s throne room because she asked me to try, and as a friend I wouldn’t refuse, but we were discovered by Zecora. Bad ending I think?
 
Fanfic time XD

I make out with Big Macintosh in Applejack’s barn as part of foreplay, and he catches me.  
I suppose the bad ending is that he woke up.

I make out with Lyra in Trixie’s wagon, because Lyra asked me to and as a friend I couldn’t refuse. Cadence walked in on us, and it ended with a happy ending.

With Cheerilee in Fluttershy’s shed because we both accidentally drank a love potion. Busted by Mayor Mare. Good ending.
 
No idea how this could turn out good in anyway, but I’ll take it.

So… I was kissing Nightmare Moon on the train to Canterlot, only to be interrupted by Trixie…
 
Uh, given that we are making out because we’re dating, and she’s the Princess of Darkness, I don’t see HOW getting caught by Trixie could result in a bad ending.
 
Unless getting slightly embarrassed is a bad ending.

So Big Mac and I were making out in the Canterlot Gardens before getting down to business but Celestia found us. That… makes perfect sense. What the hell.

I get caught making out with applejack in celestias throne room because molestia forced us too and we were busted by celestia. Good ending.
 
This is the most logical answer I’ve ever seen in a birthday game.

I make out with BobBon in Trixie’s wagon to try a non-pony and we were busted by Discord. >bad ending<

@Lillian  
Wow, people get hooked with those things.

Making out with Nightmare Moon in Trixie’s wagon and caught by Princess Luna.  
The buck?!

man, what a perfect storm… I kiss Shining Armor on the Canterlot Gardens because the motherbucker wanted to try a non-pony, and we’re surprised by none other than Princess Cadance herself… at least I got a good ending XD

I kiss Vinyl Scratch in Fluttershy’s shed so that she stops blackmailing me, but we end up being caught by Diamond Tiara, but it’s okay because we ended up using her as Bear-necessities, because her ass was on his recipes.
 
<good end>

I’m making out with shining armor in raritys botique because i wanted to try it with a pony and Big Mac walks in on us(good end) and dicides to join.

Nightmare Moon surprise kissed me on the train to Canterlot, and I was busted by Cadence and had a good ending. My name is Kino.

Okay, Town Hall on stage to prevent blackmail material from Pinkamena Diane Pie from coming out…the psycho side, not the secret keeper…and Cadance just stumbles on this scene…with Pinkie’s Hair still flat, mind you…
 
Now I’m the first human to become cupcakes.

So I make out with Braeburn in Sucarcube Corner in an attempt to gross him out so he leaves me alone, and we get busted by Trixie. Bad Ending. I don’t know what’s going to happen, help me guys! D:

Whoops, I meant caught by trixie.

Shining Armor in rarity’s boutique, then caught by Discord.

Making out with Lyra in sugar cube corner because I forced her to but I get caught by diamond tiara…O I’m in a DIRE situation

I pretended to make out with Nightmare Moon in Rarity’s Boutique (while Featherweight was taking pictures for the school’s newspaper), and Princess Cadance caught me. Thankfully, I got off easy.

I make out with Cheerilee in Applejack’s barn because I won a bet, then Big Mac walks in.
 
>Bad ending.
 
I’m screwed.

Making out with Rainbow Dash in the Canterlot gardens because she asked me to and get caught by Cadence.
 
Looking good, looking real good for once.

I am making out with King Sombra in Applejack’s barn. I get busted by Diamond Tiara, who finds out I was forcing him to do it. >Bad ending.
 
Might as well have been. There wasn’t a good part of that.

I made out with Fluttershy in Rarity’s boutique because I wanted to try kissing a pony.  
I get caught by Discord.
 
Bad ending.
 
Uh oh.