@Mismanage Assistant
Mrs. Shy looks great, like a more mature version of Fluttershy. But that’s literally all she has, that she’s an older version of her daughter, and it’s frankly as much a detriment to her as a benefit, because she’s too much like Flutters. The lady and her husband don’t even have official names, just Mr. Shy and Mrs. Shy, to denote them as Fluttershy’s parents, because that’s all that they are.

putting posey shy at C tier is criminal but at the same time you are so based for putting cream heart not into S tier. if you ask me cream heart is the most overated MILF in MLP fandom. all in all fair rating

If I did a Milf tier, who would I pick?

Canon: Pear Butter, Cup Cake, Windy Whistles, Twilight Velvet and Posey Shy.

OC: Cream Heart, Caring Hearts, Golden Brooch, Rita Cloudy and Momma Cider.

I would be asking a billion questions right here but I’m not even going to bother.

@Professor Genki  
Because a bitchy fan is a happy fan

@Thatguywiththeface  
why even question it dude? You know how this works, just look at the downvotes. nobody is ever happy

Why is chrysalis even on this list? And why is Delta V on B-tier? She’d be C on a good day(maybe) or before she split from jet.

nobody is ever happy with these, myself included. Everypony is a critic. shrug  
that being said, I should make my own but too lazy too download pics

@Zajice  
Ha ha HA! Not a fan of her. Not in the slightest. Pear Butter belongs at F tier and no higher.
 
I like your art style, by the way.

@DrCroswell  
I was on board until you insulted Pear.
 
Now I consider you a heretic and wish a blight upon you and your family.

“Why are booing me? I’m right!”
 
 
This was a joke don’t bully me pls

Golden Brooch at S tier. Totally correct. Now all that needs to happen is to move Cloudy Quartz to S tier where she belongs and move Pear Butter to F tier. Then all is right with the world.

@Phemto  
Who?

TFW you realize that you’re wife has been an A grade on a MILF tier list for 2 months and you didn’t know.  
Cinny and I are going to have to celebrate. Just wait until the rest of Ponyvania hears about this.

>Mrs. Shy is down in C tier  
>no Grace Harmony  
>Chrysalis not in Z tier
 
How can one list be so wrong?

@DeltaThePone  

 
 
Oh, wow, I actually laughed out loud at that, probably more than I should have.  
Sorry if I seem rude; it wasn’t even that bad of a mistake. That was just one of those moments when something seemingly randomly comes across as funnier at first glance than it actually is.

Beauty mark not in S? You fool.

W-what?

Windy Whistle thst high and Spoiled Rich a little high than Silverstream and Teramar brother, this weird joke, yet I can see something, but whatever

Plot twist! These are the ranks they gave to you.
 
S rank: Given to you by milfs who are exceptionally loving, and are always willing to give a partner a gold star for effort. To them, everyone in their bed goes above and beyond the call of duty.
 
A rank: Given to you by milfs who are more realistic but still adoring, and recognize that while you did a wonderful job, you’re not quite perfection. They’d still be willing to meet up again at any time you like, however.
 
B rank: Given to you by milfs who recognize that while you put in a great effort, you just weren’t everything that they wanted. In all honesty, they brought more to the bedroom than you did.
 
C rank: Given to you by milfs who have had a lot better. Don’t get them wrong, they enjoyed your time together, but your technique, stamina, and idea of what constitutes caring for your partner’s needs leave a lot to be desired.
 
D rank: Given to you by milfs who are just plain disappointed. Was this really the best you could do? You couldn’t even follow their instructions right.
 
E rank: Given to you by milfs who don’t appreciate being given crabs as a ‘gift’. They might be a high class dinner on land, but down here they’re just disgusting vermin.
 
F rank: Given to you by milfs who captured you before you even made it onto their property. What kind of prospective king can’t evade capture and fight off their queen when necessary? You’ll be lucky if you rate a light snack for her majesty.

Novo doesn’t deserve such a low ranking

Delta Vee has to be in both S and F tiers simultaneously for this to be accurate.

Spoiled Rich should definitely be placed at F-tier.

@DeltaThePone  
In my opinion, they’re all either S or A ranks.