@Background Pony  
People are upset because they’re not saying it because they’re afraid of getting sued or harassed by the perpetual victims on the other side. Like it’s a damn crime to say “Merry Christmas” or even acknowledge December 25th as anything special.
 
And stop blaming Fox News for bad media, unless you’re prepared to blame MSNBC and CNN too.

Drako:  
Christmas was in october  
this is Saint Nicholas’ day  
Cannon:  
Drako, stop ruining people’s fun

V It’s not PC. No one cared much when people said “Season’s Greetings” or “Happy Holidays” prior to the butthurt industry known as Fox News. Now, there’s been a victimization industry for a few years now. “I CAN’T SAY ‘MERRY CHRISTMAS’ BECAUSE THEY’RE BANNING ME AND TAKING AWAY MY FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS!”
 
“No, actually, you just have a devastating case of sore ass that doesn’t allow you to hear something other than ‘Merry Christmas’ grace their lips. Maybe they’ve been saying ‘Merry Christmas’ to fifty other people and they want to change things up a little so it doesn’t get monotonous, since there is the New Year and other holidays in the same vicinity of the calendar as Christmas.”
 
I still remember an incident where two Jewish boys got their asses beat for daring to say “Happy Hanukkah!”, so yes, i mad.

NOOO! IT’S SUPPOSED TO BE “HOLIDAYS”!  
YOU’RE NOT BEING PC.  
YOU’RE NOT BEING PC AT ALL!

@AchingScaphoid  
It would depend. Are they existing in a second universe accessible via portals or is it an island somewhere on our planet? If the later, yes shitstorm be a brewin’. If the earlier, then they barely would bother with our religions.

You know, this “son of the human god” is kind of insulting. I mean, it basically equals human with christian.

Hearth’s Warming Eve seems to be a lot more of an “Indepence Day” holiday rather than Christmas. The whole snow-and-ice thing doesn’t apply either, since in the southern hemisphere on Earth, December is in the middle of summer. xD

I’m trying to think of what the religious implications would be if ponies were suddenly found to be real.
 
All signs point to shitstorm.