Even funnier when you remember that the beta name of mad milk was “Mann Milk.”

Hey Applejack, I’m pretty sure everyone else here is too polite to say it so I’ll just give it to you straight.
 
You are drinking your older brother’s semen.

:D

@Applejack
 
Um… uh…
 
 
Could you ask him to get me some?
 
I’d like to try it, y’know… out of curiosity.

@Applejack
 
 
:I

Yeah, pretty good. Don’t know where he gets it though. He’s awfully quiet.

“Moo!”  
“Moo!”  
“Moo!”  
“Eeyup!”  
“Moo!”

@Applejack
 
Oooooh my.

@AJ
 
:/

@Applejack
 
Ewww

@Applejack
 
O_o  
You’ve drank that before?

“Non-milk substance.”
 
HAHAHAHAHAHA

There’s nothing quite like it!