I must punish you with tickles and hugs

@phallen1  
I’m sick of your lies…

@FirelordofHyrule  
Like this!
 

…
 
Oh, how can I be mad at that face?

@Gundlach  
Oooh! I bet she did! Wink wink, nudge nudge

So cute.

You just need to pass a [bluff] check.

You can have all the cookies you want, no need to lie. just TAKE them damn you, you cute pony.

APPLEJACK. I should have known. That farmhorse has crossed me for the last time! Thanks Pinkie.

@JonesMcPones  
Applejack’s clearly a changeling in disguise.

Applejack couldn’t have done this. Those are cookies, not apples.

Pinkie?
 
“Ok, I can’t lie to you. I did it.”
 
Good girl. You know I can’t stay mad at you. (Takes Ponk and secretly stuffs her in backpack)

Don’t lie to me, Pinkie.

Omg pinkie I did it don’t blame it on yourself.

@Pagan  
*suddenly several Apples fall out of Pinkie’s mane*
 
Apple Bloom: Uh… how did ah get in there?

Oh really? I don’t see a single apple laying around here anywhere and the sack full of apples is untouched, Don’t lie to me Pinkie.

@Sollace  

@Solitude  
“Ah can’t tell a lie… … … … Ah did it.”

Did you take a single bite out of every cookie?
 
“Like I said, applejack did it”

Oh, Pinkie Pie. You’re even adorable when you’re lying to my face like I’m some dumb jerk. How swearword dare you? (boops her cute little muzzle!)

Damnit, Applejack!