not my photo but http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lva5nrfi4D1qeuz19o1_500.jpg was my first, right before the mcdonalds toys

My first MLP toy was a brushable Fluttershy with flowers printed on one of her front legs. I think it was a Easter special.

I’m not sure if it counts (as it’s not made by Hasbro), but I have a Vinyl Scratch T-shirt my mom ordered me from Hot Topic (yes, I’ve told my mother I like MLP:FIM. She’s actually surprisingly supportive of it).

A set of Cutie Mark Pins of Twilight and Rarity. Unfortunately, I lost the Rarity pin a while ago and am waiting for the store to restock.

I bought a Pinkie Pie at a Meijers when I was supposed to be looking for Eggnog ingredients…..

I got a Rainbow Dash McD toy from a pile of rubble and broken bricks.  
Dont ask.

I got a Twilight Sparkle blindbag about a year ago. It’s still sitting on my desk at work in plain view.
 
Nobody at work has ever asked me about it. Ever.
 
My GF (of 10 years and mother of my children) visited me at work last summer, sat in my chair immediately saw it and said “What are you doing with a purple unicorn? That’s so gay!”. I lied and told her I found it.
 
I’ve mentioned since then that the show’s good but to this day she has no idea about the fandom, what a brony is and how involved I am. I’m still pretty much “In the stable”.
 
…Yeah, I know. This makes me look like a cad and I’m not too happy with myself because of it.

A Rainbow Dash keychain & T-shirt  
2 McDonalds toys: Rainbow & Twilight (lol TwiDash)

A friend gave me an AJ McDonalds toy when she heard I liked ponies.  
The first ones I bought myself were Twilight, Fluttershy, Pinkie and Rarity from the run of McDonald’s toys afterwards.

I got a Twilight Sparkle brushable - just the basic set, and it was when she still had bangs so you could style her mane properly. I didn’t plan to get any more, just my favorite.
 
Then I saw Pinkie’s car, decided it was awesome, and I had to get all of the mane six if I had two.

the pink celestia toy

AJ McD’s toy. A friend gave it to me.
 

 
Avaliable in Brazil & Latin America only, fillies

I got a Rainbow Dash shirt that’s too small (which my sis got me), and a coloring book.

@Starly:  
I did.  

My only piece of merchendice is a pink yoyo with Rainbow Dash on it.

It’s better than having no MLP shirt.

I don’t have any pony merch i really want some though.  
i tried to make a shirt but failed.  
 
Vinyl Stitch

 
4-pack of figures from Tesco. I’ve completed the mane 6 since, with AJ from a separate figure pack, and a Fluttershy I won in a 30-minute art contest.

Same as Shockblock, actually. My mom likes happy meals (Don’t ask) and she gave it to me. If only she knew…

@MaggieXawesomeness
 
Wow, the only thing I recognized in that was the k’nex.  
I’m surprised they’re still around honestly.

 
See below.

 
My first ever MLP figure I got for Christmas 2011. I’ve played with my sister’s g1s before, though. :D  
Just for brags here’s all the rest of my loot excluding my new camera, Nyan Cat shirt, and a Guinness Book.

Blindbag Cheerilee and Rarity.